American Coastal Insurance Corporation completed a $5 million share repurchase on March 11, 2026, buying back 438,746 shares at an average price of $11.40 per share through Raymond James & Associates, Inc. The transaction represents the company’s first share buyback of the year and reduces the outstanding share count while returning value to shareholders.
Prior to this repurchase, ACIC had not executed any share buybacks, despite a previous board authorization of up to $25 million. The company now has $20 million remaining in its current authorization, giving it flexibility to pursue additional repurchases if market conditions and capital needs permit. This move marks a shift from a dormant buyback program to an active capital allocation strategy.
Management highlighted that the repurchase is part of a disciplined capital management strategy tied to significant improvements in the company’s balance sheet strength and liquidity. CEO Brad Martz noted that the company’s 2025 financial results—net income of $106.8 million for the year, a 58.6% combined ratio for Q4 2025, and a substantial increase in book value per share—have bolstered the firm’s capital position. In a February 19 earnings call, Martz said the stock is “significantly undervalued” and that the company is “a good buy at the current earnings multiples.”
The share repurchase signals management’s confidence that the stock is trading below intrinsic value and that the company has sufficient liquidity to support shareholder returns. By returning capital, ACIC reinforces its commitment to delivering value while maintaining the flexibility to invest in growth opportunities or address unforeseen risks. The remaining authorization allows the board to adjust the pace of future buybacks in response to evolving market conditions and capital requirements.
The content on EveryTicker is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial or investment advice. We are not financial advisors. Consult with a qualified professional before making any investment decisions. Any actions you take based on information from this site are solely at your own risk.